This feature is under review

Audio (or other) rating in Music section

 in Site Mechanics, Design and Development

Although I thoroughly enjoy sifting through everybody's informative and highly intellectual comments on quality and not to mention, opinions on the band (ahem), I think it would be a good idea to have some kind of rating system for music. For example some people who upload do not state the bitrate. What do you, the wonderful public, think?

28 comments    3181 views    Suggested by nemesis01458 4 years and 8 months ago    

Share this idea

To share this idea use the code below and insert it into comments, status messages, forum posts or your signature.

Idea: Audio (or other) rating in Music section

Top Comments

7
jamezua1270 • 01 Feb 2014, 11:47
Well, I think that people that really loves and enjoys music always try to find the best sound quality and probably have got a good HIFI equipment at home, I don't care about downloading a massive vinyl FLAC if that brings me (with a DAC) to listen to a great audio performance, external discs are now much cheaper and ISP connections much faster, so size is not a hassle, I always choose the highest quality and bitrate in the music I upload, if people don't care about this they can download MP3, once I've heard how those FLAC 24 bits vinyl rips sounds ( big thanks to all the uploaders ) I won't ever download a MP3 again, the digital sound doesn't sound to me as good as the analogic one, the vinyls are coming back and they should never would have gone, maybe people should comment more what they download, not only thanking the uploader but the quality of the music, the recording and the rip, that's the easiest way to do it, when I give a thumbs up I don't know if it is because the download is complete and with no errors ( should I thumbs up a verified uploader? ) or what, giving more feedback is the proper way to solve this issue IMHO, and the uploaders deserve at least some appreciation for their job ...

All Comments

0
Talamasca312576 • 24 February 2015, 22:00 Show comment
great a ideapirate
0
ASSASSIN3192 • 06 February 2015, 11:22 Show comment
nice idea
0
Iseeyounow1988 • 24 December 2014, 10:36 Show comment
I would hazard a guess that a significant number of KAT users are reading this and saying to themselves "this is all Greek to me" and then just moving on.
I would hope that if the idea does in fact gain the traction it needs to come to fruition that an explanation of sorts would be made available to those who are not as tech savvy as the ones who are at the discussion, myself being an exclusion, and that the explanation is in terms that can be easily understood by everyone.

Last edited by Iseeyounow, 4 months ago

0
TomTek1643 • 20 November 2014, 22:44 Show comment
I think this is a great idea but should be applied to movies and tv shows too.
0
atifsone258 • 03 November 2014, 16:32 Show comment
good...idea
1
DauG-1nOnLy2117 • 31 October 2014, 14:08 Show comment
nice idea bro :D

here check mine clap

Idea: A reason for disliking (rating down) torrent
Show More All
Report a bug